Book Vs. Movie


As we watch the movie version of Tuck Everlasting, you will be asked to think critically about the differences between the book and the movie. For example,



  • I wish the movie hadn't changed these things:

  • I am glad the movie changed these things:

  • I am glad the movie kept these things the same:

Think about other movies you have seen of books you have read. What was the worst movie version of a book? What was the best movie version of a book? Why?


Students who leave insightful comments will be given extra credit.

9 comments:

Monica Xie said...

The worst movie of a book was The Tale of Desperaux. The book was about a mouse who dreamed about adventure. The book was amazing, but the movie was not. The movie added this whole thing with a soup festival. I don't get how the festival had to do with anything. The movie disappointed me.

The best movie of a book is Tuck Everlasting. Most movies made from books takes out a whole important chunk from the book like Twilight and Harry Potter. But in Tuck Everlasting, the movie was perfect. The parts they took out and put in didn't do much bad effect on the movie. And the movie was much more "deep" than the book. I love the movie and the book. =]

Unknown said...

Last year, I read Holes because when our teacher read us the summary on the back of the book. It seemed pretty interesting about how a kid would have to dig holes and holes and more holes, only to find out that they were supposed to find something for the person who ran the camp. She only wanted them to dig holes so she could find treasure. So, I read the book and I liked it a lot. It had so much detail and suspense. I wanted to watch the movie. When I watch ed the movie, I have to say that it was better than the book. It wasn't like Harry Potter where they left out a whole chunk of information. They only difference that I noticed was that in the book, the main character was fat. In the movive, he was skinny. That was the only difference. But the reason I liked the movie better was because they described the curse put on the main character's family in more detail. They added flashbacks, more reasons, and more detail. In most cases, if I watch the movie and read the book, the book would be better. I have only found that a couple of movies have been better than books.

Anonymous said...

The book Bridge to Terabitha has a great movie.It is about a boy named Jessie and a girl named Lessie.They inagine a land called Terabitha - full of monsters,ogers,and other magical creatures.Soon,when they cross the wood by swinging on a rope their land comes to life.Cool.Now,they are forced to battle evil to save the world.

I liked this book because the things that changed were the good and more intersting.I dont like it when the movie takes away all of the good parts that were in the book.Tuck Everlasting was the same.Good books.

Anonymous said...

The worst book that was made into a movie was "My Sister's Keeper" Becasuse the book was better. There was more suspense and affection. The part of the movie that was terrible was that the girl named Kate died becuase of cancer and in the book she doesn't die. But her sister, Anna dies in the book instead. In the book they believe, that Anna dies so Kate can live. I hated the difference and I know a lot of other people did too. In my opinion it ruined the movie totally.
The best book that became a movie was Tuck Everlasting. It might have left out some parts that were in the book, but it tied all together perfectly. This movie was so good I cried. I think the movie showed more affection, suspense, emotion and was definately easy to visualize and cry over like I did. Esspecially the parts when Miles tells Winnie about his kids and wife and how they left him. ALso when Jesse went to see Winnie's grave. Those parts were very sad, very thought out ,and very emotional. But all in all I liked both!! =) -Kimberly Solinski-

Priyanka Patel said...

The best movie of the book was Bridge to Terabithai which I am sure you probaly all have read. I truly think both the movie and the book were amzing. In the book.. I could imagine every single solitary thing that they stated. It was a fantastic movie. The movie had all the main parts in them like when Leslie Burke died and how Jesse got bullied by this girl that everyone hated.

It was just like Tuck Everlasting. I think the book and movie were awesome because they didn't take out any of the main parts. Overall I luv the movie and also the book:)

Priyanka B. said...

I read a book called Ella Enchanted. It was one of the best books on Earth. After I finished the book, I watched the movie. The movie wasn't good at all. The movie had many changes. The movie added in bad parts and took out good parts. The movie was short, the book was long and descriptive. The movie was HORRIBLE.

I also read another book called Matilda. Matilda was awesome. Wonderful. I finished the book and watched the movie. The movie was just as good as the book:Wonderful. It didn't have many changes. The characters were more or less the same. The plot was too. Adding parts was ok because it went with the plot of the book. So this was the greatest movie of a book I have ever watched.

M said...

The worst movie adaptation of a book was Twilight. I read Twilight in early 2008 and when I found out that there was going to be a movie for Twilight, I was so excited! Once I saw it, I realized that I just wasted $10 on the movie. It was horrible! Twilight is about 500 pages and the movie was only 2 hours. To me, it was a waste of 2 hours. A major difference was that in the book, Bella found out that Edward was a vampire during the car ride home from Port Angeles. In the movie, she finds out in the meadow. I expected the movie to be much better. The best movie adaptation is probobly Tuck Everlasing. Basically every detail in the book was in the movie. I especially liked Tuck Everlasting(the movie)because the part about Mae hitting the man in the yellow suit with a shotgun was still there. It is a very important part that is needed to understand the plot. Tuck Everlasting did not disappoint me. In fact, it surprised me because I didn't expect the movie to be that good.

Shivil said...

I read the book Sleepy Hollow. The book was ok, but the movie was great. I think the movie was better. It was better because the movie made the book ALIVE.
The book as it went on got boring. However, the movie was full of exitement, and horror. So the book was better.
- Hardyz_RoCk

Anonymous said...

A book I read that was turned into a movie was Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix.It was the worst Harry Potter book and the worst Harry Potter movie.The book was I think 810 or 813 pages long and it was full of useless garbage J.K. Rowling added in for no reason.It made me mad that there was no excitement and that there was no suspense in the end.I was hoping the movie might be better.Boy was I wrong.The movie starts out pretty good.But it turns out to be horrible.They could have added some of the stuff that happend in the book.Like the date with Cho Chang.The ending was okay,but kind of harder to understand.Dumbledores talk was kind of not focused on.

The best movie version of a book is Narnia The Lion The Witch and the Wardrobe.I love the book a lot.But the movie is amazing.I love the whole thing.I've watched it about 5 times and I love it so so much.It is so enchanting.Better than many of the Harry Potter movies.Probably the best version of the book ever.I don't care about the book.Or remember it.I just love the movie.I think the book is just great and amazing,but its no match for the movie.