Excavate or Conserve?



We have read several selections about the eruption of Mount Vesuvius in AD 79 and the consequences for the ancient Roman town of Pompeii. Our first selection said, "Pompeii and its people live on today in timeless permanence, their city transformed by Vesusius's fury into a miraculous survivor of the ancient world." However, as we continued to read some recent articles about the ancient town we discovered that today Pompeii is in danger of dying its second death. The gradual decline and erosion of the Pompeiian ruins has recently caused Pietro Giovanni Guzzo, the superintendent of the site, to declare a halt on all further excavations. He decided that all funds should be diverted into conservation of the remains that have already been unerathed. This has caused controversy amongst historians and archaeologists, and has become the center of the debate on whether to focus on conservation or excavation. Classicists argue that only by continuing excavations can more ancient texts be found to reveal more about ancient Roman life.


What do you think? Excavate or conserve?

Learn some more about Pompeii:
 Click  here to go on virtual field trip to Pompeii. Lots of great photographs, videos and maps.

Click here to watch a video of Pliny's eyewitness account.

Click here to build your own virtual volcano!






5 comments:

Priyanka Patel said...

I chose to excavate Pompeii because we can then discover the hidden remains of the buried city. If we continue to preserve... there could be a chance that the city could die out, so it's better to excavate and find all the secrets about Pompeii hidden in the depths of the buried city. :)

Monica Xie said...

Conservation. The walls and stuctures of Pompeii is already crumbling down because of animals, plants, humans, and air itself. Like Pietro Giovanni Guzzo said, Pompeii is "in danger of dying its second death." Excavation can find more information of Pompeii, but will also lead to demolition of what we already have. It is best to conserve what we already have, and once the structures are stable, they could continue exacavating the rest of Pompeii.

Aqsa Khan said...

Conservation because if we dont preserve and continue exavating, we will waste all our money on new exavations that they will not be enough money to preserve all the findings. they'll be no point in finding all these hidden treasures if they cannot be preserved for us to see. STOP EXAVATION!!! :)

Nabihah said...

I think we should conserve Pompeii. We have things to study already. There are papyri we haven't read yet, why would we need more? If we conserve what we have and spend our money on that, what we have of Pompeii, so far, will last longer. No unstable buildings will crumble for us to lose memory of. If we conserve what we have, no buildings will be falling atop the tourists and no one will get hurt. Pompeii will remain a wonderful blast from the past.

Anonymous said...

I choose to conserve. I said so because all the excavation is ruining Pompeii. All the buildings are coming down and these sites are now being closed to vistioors because they can be dangerous to them.We want Pompeii to exist, not destroy.